Sailing the Ship of Theseus on Heraclitus’s River, Something about Hitler’s Urine, Setting Things on Fire, and Other Perfectly Reasonable Attempts at Achieving Inner Peace: An Essay on Change, Chaos, Questionable Wisdom, and Knowing When to Give a Fuck

Share

There was this Greek philosopher, an absolute killjoy he was, and he wrote:

“You cannot step into the same river twice.”

And, since I hate being told what to do, I went and looked at a goddamned river and realized that the water is taking a little bit of every rock with it as it makes its way to the sea. And in a drop of water, you find about a sextillion water molecules, and at any given moment, the river is moving millions of drops. The exact configuration of the landscape, the water, the rocks, the air… The river won’t ever exist again.

And with how similar the river will be tomorrow, we may decide that it’s irrelevant, but some of these drops of water were inside a dinosaur before, and some others were definitely inside Hitler, and some were in both.

But the important part of the whole scenario is that this is exactly how the world works: Everything stays exactly the same forever until, one day, you look around and everything has changed, and you didn’t notice because sometimes change is sudden, but most change comes drop by drop. And if you remember that our divisions of time are arbitrary conventions we use to observe the world, the concept of “now” and the subdivisions of the river become increasingly fine, with each state becoming more similar to those immediately around it.

So, what to do about it? You look up the approximate location of Heraclitus’s grave and you piss on it. Let him figure out if it’s the same water or what river it came from.

And then, obviously, Buddha came and said:

“All conditioned things are impermanent.”

Like a ship. If you’re sailing on a ship, then you get the feeling that the ship is permanently a ship, right? But that ship used to be wood growing in a forest, which was carbon floating around in the atmosphere before that, which was part of other forests and animals before. And don’t even get me started on the metal.

Metallic elements start their lives in the cores of stars that eventually explode and send millions of tons of material hurtling through eternity, delivering it to worlds by way of honest-to-God violence. Asteroids crash, and the material gets mixed with other materials, and then handy monkeys go and fucking dig it up and smelt it, heat it, shape it, and force it to float on water like it’s not an aberration, or even worse, through the air in airplanes.

And then, obviously, the ship will stop being useful, or a captain will try to steer it with his dick like the captain of the Costa Concordia did, and the ship itself gets a lesson in impermanence. Not before some idiot decides to ask: What happens if you sail the Ship of Theseus down Heraclitus’s river? Exactly. Reality collapses.

But the ship has always been here, and it will always be here, in a way. Its material, however, will only take the shape of a ship and hold it through human will and work. So, the idea of the ship is as important to its existence as the work used to build it, throw it into the water, and sail it around.

And that makes human effort and work valuable. Because even if we have a lot of ships and cars as a species, in the grand scheme of things, these are precious, rare things in a universe that is—probably—indeed infinite, but infinitely empty.

Matter rejected entropy so hard that it started thinking, and in doing so, it made other matter reject entropy as well.

Change is at the core of everything. Change is a constant, the constant. We don’t experience change on a schedule; we’re changing every second of every day, and so is everything and everyone around us. We’re moving around in so many directions simultaneously that we get to experience the illusion of being still.

And that’s the thing Heraclitus and Buddha were warning everyone about: You can’t stop a river from flowing with your hands. Actually, you can’t stop it at all. The water will flow no matter what, and exactly like that, you can’t stop change. But you can adapt to it.

And, coming from me, I guess you’re thinking this is another preachy essay about learning to let go. Well, not exactly. In Chinese philosophy, we find the concept of yin and yang.

Yin represents everything that is receptive, pointing inward, dark, and cold. You can interpret yin as evil if you’re shallow and like to be wrong, or at least as chaotic and destructive. Every time something is surrendered, lost, or dies, you can think of it as flowing toward yin.

Yang represents the active, expansive, bright, and outward-moving aspects of reality. When you decide to double down, create, or commit, when something grows, it’s flowing toward yang.

But there’s a catch. You can flow toward yin and be doing something constructive, moral, or objectively good for yourself or others, or vice versa. And this is important.

Let’s take another detour just because I like the sound of my own voice: In alchemy and some branches of the occult—keep it hidden, it doesn’t work—there’s a very interesting concept: solve et coagula. Dissolve and solidify. Yin and yang, create and destroy, not as opposites but as sides of the same process that’s been going on since the beginning and whose end would mean, well, the end. The heat death of the universe. Nothing beyond.

Am I saying you should call your ex and get back together because this time it’ll all flow toward yang, with minimal solve, if any? No. Put the phone down.

How do we navigate a universe that is constantly, absolutely changing? Through choice.

“Often a man does wrong by not doing something, not only by doing something.”

— Marcus Aurelius

We can’t force the circumstances, and we can’t reshape the world, not completely, but we can choose. And choice is the rudder we use to navigate change. And the problem—and the beauty—is that we have only a degree of control. We can move toward an objective, but we can’t ensure we’ll get there. Or we can aim to avoid something and still end up exactly there, because our choices influence our direction without guaranteeing our destination.

And wisdom ends up meaning: Being good at distinguishing when to steer and when to let the current take you, and especially being open enough and paying enough attention that you can change your choice whenever necessary.

How’s that Alcoholics Anonymous prayer? May as well learn it already:

“God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.”

Serenity. Peace. Balance. That’s, in the end, what being in tune and at peace with change means. Embracing the current and taking the sadness and the joy, the sanity and the crazy, with the same calm because pain is inevitable, but suffering is often optional.

And balance, thankfully, also means acting badly about half the time, and for me, that’s quite peace-inducing. Sometimes forgiving an enemy, sometimes setting something on fire. Works perfectly for me.

Read more

You Paid All the Installments and Still Don’t Own Her? On Emotional Capitalism, Romantic Esquirols, Industrialized Courtship, the Unreasonable Expectation of Getting Laid, and Other Tragedies of the Modern Gentleman: An Essay on the Friendzone

We’re no strangers to evil and controversy here in hell. How could we be? We’re already damned. We have tackled a lot of complex, dangerous, morally grey (and pitch-black) subjects with all the grace I’m known for when I write. But Nazis, Leopold, the Brits, and

By Sisyphus

Dark Secrets from My Youth, a Muddy Motorcycle Ride, Half a Missing Lung, Sexually Deviant Nurses, and the Abusive Little Bastard Who Made Me Who I Am — An Essay on Perfectionism, Survival, and the Perverse Pleasure of Never Being Good Enough

I just got home. I rode my motorcycle a few kilometers to deliver something to a friend who lives out of town, and I had to get there along a bad road and through a bit of darkness. Diagnosis? Very fun. Got mud all over my pants, but mission accomplished.

By Sisyphus